Thursday 03 November, 2011

Occupy Nashville Open Letter to Governor Haslam


Dear Governor Haslam,

Can we start anew?  Please allow us to introduce ourselves properly: We are Occupy Nashville, a citizen-led movement defending democracy from corporate money and corruption.

We are here on Legislative Plaza because we are deeply concerned by undue corporate influence in government.  The longer we stay here, the more people understand why we are here, and join our numbers.  Our continuing presence communicates the depth of our feeling and our commitment to positive change louder than words.

Lately, our First Amendment rights were upheld, first by Judge Thomas Nelson at the Night Court and then by Judge Aleta Trauger at the Federal Court.  We are deeply gratified by the support that we have from the people of the city of Nashville, the state of Tennessee, and elsewhere, as expressed on your Facebook page, our Facebook page, the online comments and polls of the Tennessean newspaper and dozens of blogs and editorial columns.  It seems that democracy is alive and well in the state of Tennessee.  We are happy that Legislative Plaza is available once more, not only to us, but to anyone who wishes to exercise their rights under the First Amendment.

We are also extremely proud, that during over 50 arrests having no probable cause, that there was not one act of violence or hostility on the part of any of our members.  We also appreciate the essential humanity of the Tennessee police services and are grateful that in Nashville we have not seen the deplorable injuries that have taken place in other cities.

We have a new, better assembly layout on the plaza and an improved management plan.  We had off-site sanitation arrangements before, but now we’d like to have controlled facilities on site.  We are looking forward to welcoming the people of Tennessee and beyond to our assembly.  We have a lot to share with them.  We have just updated our website, occupynashville.org, to explain more about who we are and why we’re here.

Governor Haslam, we plan on being here for a while, and we would like to be good neighbors.  The plaza is a safe, clean and welcoming place as long as we work together to keep it that way.  We would like to collaborate with your team to achieve the best possible outcomes.  We’re not interested in name-calling or slander. It does nobody any good and all it does is diminish the fine reputation of Nashville.  We love Nashville and we believe you do too.

We look forward to hearing from you soon, Governor.

Best regards,

Occupy Nashville

  • Pingback: Occupy Nashville Looking to Discuss ‘Best Possible Outcomes’ with Haslam Administration | Tennessee Report

  • Loveliz77

    This is a good letter and I hope the Governor and state officials read it and can respond in positive kind. National media has noted the conflict and resolution that has happened in Nashville and it is something to be proud of. Let us continue in intelligent conversation to solve the many problems that we face.

  • Chas

    So, what is it exactly that you want?

    What does “victory” look like?

    • Jacob Mazac

      Victory looks like the Governor speaking to the federal government in the best interest of the people- the 99%. Once he is on our side and we are on the same page, instead of only communicating with the people he feels are worthy to discuss issues with(Corporate business leaders- Millionaires..), we will have a victory.

      • nwo5150

        No one can tell the Corporate business leaders to give you something so give it up moron!!

        • RickTNRebel

          I smell some troll doo-doo…I think it’s in your post

          • nwo5150

            Sad and pathetic that’s all people like you have when someone states actual facts! If the government could tell people (which is what corporations are a group of people) you idiots could be told to go home and shower!!

      • Tools93Red

        What does the Governor speaking to the federal government have to do with your protest of Wall Street? If you group is so righteous, why not go to Washington and speak for yourselves?

        • RickTNRebel

          @Tools83red: You must not know sh*t from shinola when it comes to “grass roots” movements. They work this skinhead…from the roots up…now can you wrap head around the concept? Do you know why the path is thru LOCAL governing bodies? Read a book man, fox news is rotting your brain.

          • Tools93Red

            Typical leftist, you can only start calling people names and insulting them when you can’t discuss things on point. Oh, I understand, too many of you want something you did not earn but want a nanny state to take care of you. Maybe we should donate pampers to your cause, caust your going to need them.

          • Has a clue

            Actually, Fox News, CNN, MSNBC are all mind-numbing, brainwashing, tools of the corporation. All main stream media is controlled by a few, including radio, billboards and newspapers. That is why the blogosphere and internet is feared. There are many disinfo sites online, too.

            Check out the link below to see how most of the populace gets their info. It’s disgusting.

            http://theeconomiccollapseblog.com/archives/who-owns-the-media-the-6-monolithic-corporations-that-control-almost-everything-we-watch-hear-and-read

    • nwo5150

      “victory” to them is that everyone is as miserable as they are!

      • RickTNRebel

        Gadafi said that same crap you just said! He really didn’t like them “pesky protesters” either. He traded his ivory tower for a filthy, stinkin’ sewer pipe…where do see yourself ending up?

      • Tnhighwayfan

        No one can tell the Corporate business leaders to give you something so give it up moron!!
        Really? What did Bank of America among others just do? I’ll give you a second to look it up……did you find it? Yeah there’s your proof that we can.

        • Dartania

          Highwayfan,
          There’s no reason to call people morons.
          You need to consider that the method the 1% uses to continue amassing more power and more and more wealth is by redirecting the attention of us 99% toward one another and away from them.
          They want you to hate us. They want you to call us names, and they want us to hate you and call you names.
          Its a shell game. “Pay no attention to that man behind the screen…” Unless you’re Bill Haslam, you and I have a lot more in common than you think. I’m just a little bit ahead of you on the curve of understanding what’s going down.
          When all of the money is in the hands of the few, the many
          are reduced to serfdom. If the income inequality in the US
          continues along its current trajectory, our country will soon
          be unrecognizable.

        • nwo5150

          Typical dirty hippy ………. BTW your “protest” had nothing to do with Bank of America it was their customers !!

    • Dartania

      Well, Chas, for one thing, victory would be the end of Corporate Person Hood. Victory would be a clamp down on the corruption that pervades our
      government. (Local, state, and federal). It would be putting an end to the currently accepted cronyism, kickbacks, and contempt for fair play and opportunities for the “little people”. Victory would be our political representatives responding to the wishes and needs of the 99%, instead of catering to every whim of the 1%.

      Victory would be when someone like you has an epiphany and finally understands how damaging the loss of a strong middle class has been for our country and our economy. Victory would be when you understood
      that the degree of income inequality the US now has is greater than many
      third world countries and its dangerous to our society and our country’s
      future.

    • Chas

      Based on the responses, it sounds like “victory” is making sure that no one is more successful than anyone else.

      • tvwav

        Ain’t it like most people? I’m no different
        We love to talk on things we don’t know about

        Don’t know Chas, the outcome of any action is never known; but even Marx himself never envisioned nor promoted such an idea; but i doubt seriously that you have ever read any work by any philosopher or great thinker- including those whose ideas formed the nation in which you now live. The greatest mind in your universe is you!

        (Don’t know why i haven’t tried this before- this ad hominem stuff is fun!)

  • Douglas Stephens

    The right to assemble does not include the right to camp.

    • Jacobmazac

      We can assemble for as long as we want and untill the outcomes we want come out

      • Tools93Red

        But where do you get the right to camp. Who is paying for the electricity your group is using while on the plaza.

        • nwo5150

          funny you mention electricty ……… they were protesting about NES when they are stealing power!!!

        • MerryinMemphis

          I doubt very seriously that “all Americans” will descend on the capitol bldg in DC for any reason but especially the garbled chaotic message the occupy movement seems to use. How is having an extended camping party realistically making a difference to Wall Street, DC or good ‘ole Nahsville? I’ve posted on this blog before and not had any replies and I’ve noticed only 1 new post since yesterday. So here’s my thinking on the whole occupy thing. No one has heard of the Occupy Nashville group since the arrests have stopped. No news channel is covering it anymore because it was a blip, a boring blip. Fun for those actually involved but of no consequence to ANYBODY else. Would somebody PLEASE reply and tell me what sitting in the plaza has accomplished?

      • propp10

        What is the outcome? There are so many different stories floating around that know knows who to believe anymore.

  • Salty123

    You are bunch of stupid, dirty hippies who need the crap kicked out of them

    • Tnhighwayfan

      Armchair tough guy. You would have fit in well in pre WW2 Germany. Please give valid reasons for your anger. I’m sure the remote is next to you so turn off fox news and read a book, newspaper, or find common sense.

    • Tnhighwayfan

      Oh and you forgot to put an A but lowercase between are and bunch, but hey, what does this stupid hippie know.

      • Salty123

        Spelling smack, nice. Yep, about what I would expect from people like you. Stupid, dirty, hippie.

        • nwo5150

          That’s all they have when they are called out!

    • RickTNRebel

      Salty, you should read the pledge of solidaridy letter from the citizens of Cairo. Since they have already been thru this in their country, they are providing advice and pledging their support (they are also reading this website). Salty, the “need the crap kicked out of them” part of your post may sadly be the eventual direction this thing takes. Corporate “gate keepers” like yourself threatening violence against American citizens. As a former U.S. Marine, I can assure you I will be on that battlefield in defense of my fellow Americans. I’ll be lookin’ for ya buddy.

      • Salty123

        Yeah, I am really frightened there, jarhead. Just for the record, I never threatened anything. What I said is that scum like you need a good ass kicking.

      • Lcpenneygal

        I hate to say it Rick, But with a name like Salty, I think he is gonna kick your ass! LOL Just saying…LOL

    • Has a clue

      And your sentiment is the reason why we have the people that we do in govt. Those who think violence, oppression and intolerance is the answer gain power and will control an apathetic populace.

      We actually get the govt we deserve. Until we don’t. What you are witnessing is a revolution of thought and peaceful action that will not be stopped. I have hope for humanity to awaken and shake off it’s oppressors. This usually starts with intellectual dialogue and awareness.

      • Salty123

        And I resent idiots like you pretending that you have the right to speak for me. I am sure you believe you are an intellectual when you are, in fact, a stupid, dirty hippie.

        • Dartania

          Hey Salty,
          I’m a small business owner. I’m not a stupid dirty hippie.
          I side with the Occupy Wall Streeters and Occupy Nashville.
          We need to do something to change the trajectory of income
          disparity in this country. If we don’t, we are headed for serious unrest. With the economy in the toilet, its getting more and more difficult for graduates to find jobs and for those who’ve been laid off to find new jobs.
          I know many people in their 40′s and 50′s who’ve been
          displaced from jobs they worked at for years.
          They’ve used up their savings. They have no health insurance. And, now companies are not hiring anyone who
          doesn’t have a job already. Corporations have outsourced our manufacturing and made us very vulnerable to other country’s whims. If there were a war, we no longer have the
          apparatus in place to build what we need and even process our food. Middle American’s wages are flat. They haven’t risen in 20 years, and the top 1% are the richest they’ve been since 1928, just before the crash of 1929.
          Republican’s are trying to dismantle our social safety net just when we need it the most. We need to overturn “Citizen’s United” and end corporate person hood.
          You need to look inside yourself and figure out why you are
          so filled with hate toward people who are fighting this fight.
          But, no matter what, the movement has started and will continue with or without people like you.
          http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5iAIM02kv0g

          • Tools93Red

            Isn’t the only way to elimnate corporate personhood is to eliminate the corporation?
            Are we going to eliminate the person hood of all unions as well?

          • Dartania

            Tool –
            We don’t need to eliminate corporations.
            We just need to eliminate their status as
            “Persons”
            I’ll accept that corporations are people when Texas executes one of them.

            Unions are a bugaboo, but they don’t scare me like they appear to scare you. I saw first hand how they raised the standard of living for all
            workers when I was growing up in Michigan. There are very few of them left in the US. This is one of the reasons for the Third World level of income equality in our Country.
            Relying on corporations and big business to provide a decent living for their employees is
            foolish. They have outsourced countless jobs
            to places like China where they can pay someone $14 a day. They charge the consumer the same, and then pass the increased profit onto the dividend holders.
            Most US citizens are not dividend holders.
            50% of US citizens make less than 26 grand a year. They can barely afford to pay attention,
            much less invest in stocks.
            You can stick your fingers in your ears and sing lalala all you want, but unless you are
            a member of the 1%, you’re like a chicken
            advocating for KFC.

          • Tools93Red

            There are many jobs out there. People need to be willing to go to work. Let me see, no pay check in one hand, a paycheck in the other hand, which do I want? Tough question I know for some folks. I don’t have a college education but I have a great job. What I do most people don’t want to do, makes it easy for me to find work!! But I praise God that he gave me my job, I was just prepared by improving my skills so when the offer came my way I was ready.

          • Has a clue

            Then you are fortunate. Hopefully, you never find yourself otherwise. Many people cannot find jobs. Any job. The number of positions relative to applicants is staggering.

        • Has a clue

          Far from it. I decided to attend a protest and GA to see for myself what was going on. That’s why I feel like I need to speak out.

          I just don’t resort to name calling. I prefer to speak with people in a respectful and intelligent manner. You can continue the name calling, it speaks volumes about you.

      • Lcpenneygal

        Get the Lawyers out of Washington and let the common man get in there and deal with the Politics end of it. Too many elitists.

        • Be aware

          That is certainly one of a litany of things that should be remedied.

          The common man is protesting a great deal of the ills in our global society, yet you view that with disdain.

      • Tools93Red

        What violence has the republican party caused?

        What oppression has the republican party caused?

        What is the intolerance that the republican party cause?

        • Be aware

          I don’t buy into the left/right paradigm any longer. Politics only serve to keep us minions divided.

          Your questions are seemingly sincere, though. The republican party is a war mongering party. Do you ever question why we are in the wars that we are across this globe? Do you ever question the official statements put out by our govt? Do you buy into the war on terror? The war on drugs?

          Not that the democrat party is any better. They are two sides of the same coin. Both sides worship at the the altar of the federal reserve. The monetary policies (think petro dollar) have caused violence, oppression and intolerance across the globe.

    • Lcpenneygal

      They all left their smart pills at home…

  • Tools93Red

    Where does the constitution give a group of people the right to camp? Assembly is one thing but occupation of public property and making a camp ground out of it is not guaranteed by the constitution. And another thing, if you are protesting Wall Street, what does your group expect the governor to do regarding Wall Street, since running Tennessee has nothing to with the folks on Wall Street.

    • Has a clue

      The constitution affords one the right to peaceably assemble. There isn’t an asterisk or a footnote indicating how this is accomplished or why it should be done. One doesn’t need permission to exercise a right. We seem to be asking permission collectively though. May I carry a gun? May I have a permit to protest? See how this ends up being a problem?

      Corruption and fraud is at all levels across the globe. How effective would it be to have all Americans descend on the capitol bldg in DC or wall street in NY? How long could Americans realistically do that?

  • propp10

    The right to assemble does not include the right to break laws that have been on the books. The plaza has a curfew for a reason, you were arrested for breaking that law, and countless others have been overlooked. You are making fools out of yourselves, and trashing up a beautiful city with your insane requests. Why should anyone forgive your student loans? No one held a gun to your head and made you go to college. It’s folks like you that take things way too far. The only ones that are taking you seriously are the ones as jacked up as you are. Gov Haslam has way more sense than to give you bozos even a second thought. Why don’t you people go home, give us our city back and quit acting like a bunch of spoiled brats.

    • Dartania

      Propp10 –
      Its our city too. Its our country too. Sleeping out in the cold and the rain for a principle and a cause is not acting like a spoiled brat.
      Its difficult and it takes conviction. We ridicule and deride the things we
      don’t understand and fear the most. You need to search inside your soul
      to find the reason you are so hostile to a group of people trying to make things better for all of us.

      • MerryinMemphis

        How is “Sleeping out in the cold and rain” making things better for anybody? If it’s so horrible, why not do something that will ACTUALLY make an impact to anyone besides yourselves and those inconvienced by you being in the way? Hand written signs and chants aren’t going to change anything. How long has it been already? Have you made even an iota of difference?

        • MerryinMemphis

          Oh, and I forgot to say, I am totally ok with the protests and the protesters, I have no problem with it and agree every single American has the right to protest …. whatever…. as long as they don’t break any laws while protesting … whatever it is they want to protest. I just don’t see THIS TYPE of protest accomplishing anything for anybody. It seems like a huge waste of time and resources that could be put to better use elsewhere…like say…Washington?

    • RickTNRebel

      Where did you read “forgiving student loans” as one of the movement demands? Did you read ANYTHING before you popped off at the mouth here? Let’s see how names you called your fellow Americans in your “spoiled brat” post; “Fools” (insane requests) “Folks like you”(jacked up) “bozos” and the icing on the cake, “spoiled brats”. It’s been my experience that “spoiled brats” are almost always the first people to resort to childish name calling…just sayin’

    • TheLikesOfUs

      Please recall that there was no law on the books regarding the Plaza, as demonstrated by the decisions of the Night Court and Federal Judges. There is also no public nuisance from the assembly that did not exist before the assembly.

      That’s the tricky thing about rights, isn’t it. People who you don’t like and don’t agree with have them too. And sometimes they want to use them in ways you don’t like and don’t agree with. Thankfully, they don’t need your approval. If the day comes when you want to exercise your rights in a manner that other people don’t like and don’t agree with, I hope you will appreciate their forbearance and reconsider your present attitude.

  • Tools83Red

    Does this group want Wall Street and everyone associated with it to shut down and cease to exist. That would end corporate greed.

    • Gwpeters

      Ignorance will get you just where you are now. Please read out purpose and goals to understand the depth of the issues.

      • Kingofthehill2007

        You are calling him ignorant? You losers are sleeping outside on the plaza eating donated food and he’s ignorant? Not two of you have the same reason for this “STUPID” protest except “corporate greed” and what is that exactly? Just because a corporation or a individual becomes successful doesn’t mean they have to cut you a check. It doesn’t mean they have to do anything but continue to do their best to be successful . Since this “gravy train ” of you losers is about to come to an end, here is something for you to try. Go home (if you still have one) take a bath change clothes ( get rid of the sandals) and get your own. This is the greatest country in the world and if you can’t make it here you won’t make it anywhere. Instead of sitting and crying fowl cause everyone has more than you go and get your own.

        • RickTNRebel

          Gwpeters didn’t call anyone ignorant, you made that sh*t up for your own mind so you could treat GW to your dose of abusiveness…but then, referring to yourself as some sort of “king” in a land of democracy is without a doubt, only something a dum bass, IGNORANT, corporate “gate keeper” like you sees himself as. Go ahead scumbag, call ME a loser.

          • Lcpenneygal

            We are NOT a Democracy! How many times do I have to say that! Gosh, Rick Go back to Government class!

        • Lcpenneygal

          Its funny how they all have Lap tops to do their live streams and Ipods, Ipads and Iphones to text, call and surf with. Who do they think they made rich buying these items! LOL And the fact that they think they are owed something, just because they made the wrong choices in life. Or went into debt over that student loan! No one held a gun to their head to make them sign for the loan, did they? And why isn’t the media talking about the countless rapes and sexual assalts on people at OWS? Why is this being covered up? Life wouldn’t be exciting if S*it didn’t happen! LOL

          • Be aware

            When were any of us given a choice in technology? I suppose they could record this protest and we could watch it on VHS, but that would be ridiculous and nearly impossible. Perhaps we could take tin photos like they did in the civil war. I think that the technology should be used to it’s full advantage. The twenty-something generation doesn’t know anything other than the technology in use today. Think about it.

            Do you really not see what a racket a college education is? How many poli-sci, women’s studies, law, economic degrees, etc. do we need in this country? Why is the cost of a decent education outpacing inflation? Why do football coaches at universities make so much money just to simply coach a sport? How is it that you need a college degree to get a job that really doesn’t always require one? If one doesn’t have a college degree, is there a manufacturing sector left in this country where one can work? Do we manufacture much in this country anymore? Look around your house. Most of your possessions are imported from China, Japan, Taiwan, etc.

            What do you think a dying empire looks like? Of course the media (owned by SIX corporations) is going to paint this movement in the worst light possible. How would one expect them to react at the prospect of losing control and not being able to manipulate the masses any longer? There will always be those that can and will be manipulated, but one shouldn’t be angry with those of us who are fed up with the deceit, corruption, lying, control, fraud and tyranny that has been a blight on the populace throughout history.

  • Carol Shaw

    There are many instances of grassroots movements being successful with little money. This is the principle of WE THE PEOPLE. However, the small victory of being able to stay on the Plaza for the present time has not been affected by WE THE PEOPLE, it was affected by WE THE ATTORNEYS.

    I have made MANY inquiries with the legislators and their staff who work at Legislative Plaza, and NONE of them have had ANY of your “occupyers” to come into the building, to a legislative office, and request a meeting with the legislators to discuss the issues. Lobbying is the politcal term for Educating. When all of the information is filtered through the media, the legislators are left to form their own opinions, based on reporting that is intended to sell newspapers, and media advertising. Whoever your “organizers” are are making you appear to be less than well-educated grassroots activists.

    If your primary goal is to influence the Governor, and not address the legislators, then you should move your encampment to the Capitol grounds where the Governor’s office is located, and leave the LEGISLATIVE Plaza.

    One final comment, as I read and see in the media comments by some of the “occupyers”, it strikes me as very inappropriate that individuals talk about leaving their jobs and homes in Kentucky, Virginia and other states to take up “squatters quarters” on the TENNESSEE legislative plaza. Go protest in YOUR state. The Tennessee government and its offices and grounds are the public forum of TENNESSEANS.

    Your efforts, even to many who support your concepts, are embarrassing.

    • RickTNRebel

      Well, thank you very much for sharing your observations, the conclusions you’ve obviously jumped to and all of the derogatory (right wing) suggestions you’ve volunteered so we can make improvements in efficiency and effectiveness. As far as us “leaving” or “going home” because you feel embarrased? Well, we probably ain’t gonna do that. You see, the name of the movement is “Occupy”…how can we call it occupy if we all go home?

      • Nra4ever

        You’re not really that dumb are you Rick? Carol suggested squatters from other states to go home, not people from TN.

    • Trailhiker

      Hey Carol – you sound like one of those spoiled state workers that gets a ridiculous salary and unmentionable benefits. Is that who you are? Well sorry for the inconvenience that the people who pay your salary have caused you. Just step over our poor, starving bodies on your way to your 2 hour lunch (likely paid for by us taxpayers). Or, better yet, go out and get a job in the real world like the rest of us and support yourself so that we don’t have to. I hope you are reading this at work – while my money pays your lazy a$$.

  • Macfanatic51

    Occupy Wall Street is just the first step. The second step is reclaiming control of our money and our purchasing power and our capital. Credit Unions are a great way to invest in your community, and to keep money out of the hands of the banks. learnmore.asmarterchoice.org has some good illustrations of how the banks behave, as well as info on credit union benefits.

  • Anonymous

    Occupiers, many thanks to you. Detractors, many of your criticisms are good common sense. But something other than common sense has brought us to where we are. We all believe in democracy, but true democracy would never put so much power is in so few hands. If the system worked as advertised, occupying public space in protest would not be necessary. Why not come down to Legislative Plaza and experience a different kind of democracy? You’ve got brothers and sisters there, working for you and for all of us.

    • Lcpenneygal

      We aren’t a democracy! Republic, republic, republic

      • Be aware

        Please see my post above. What are your thoughts?

      • Johanne

        I think it’s important to acknowledge a republic as a form of government in which the people have supreme control over the government, and where officials are elected or chosen by elected representatives. Our organization, although it exists within the republic of the USA, does not have elected leaders. Instead, we follow a democratic process based on equal and direct participation in the development, proposal, and agreement of our actions and petitions. If you would like to know more about this, come to a General Assembly or visit our FAQ page

  • RickTNRebel

    Look occupiers, don’t let trolls and abusive scumbags come onto these boards and post their crap without someone responding in kind. They’ve got to know early on that we will rigorously defend ourselves. That is the best deterrance to violence. If you let these weasels post here and they think they can “run” you like povlovs dogs, they’ll continue to advance…next thing you know, they’ll be showing up at the Plaza trying to verbally abuse you like the do on the boards. Stop them early here at the boards before one of the dumbshits think they can throw some punches on the Plaza, or worse. Some sites run “troll control” as part of their security group-just a couple at a time patrolling the boards in shifts…take notes- ESPECIALLY if one of them communicates a threat.

    • Salty123

      You are such a bad ass. If only all the hippies could be like you.

      • Richard

        salty where u at ill come whip ur punk ass and im not there bitch what do u have against a hippie ?

        • Salty123

          I am so frightened of a stupid, dirty, smelly, disgusting, uneducated hippie like you. Go occupy a shower

  • Has a clue

    The majority of the populace across the globe get their info from the same sources. This same majority will also exhibit Stockholm syndrome in light of the facts and defend the status quo and their status in life out of fear, apathy and willful ignorance. Not everyone will awaken nor are they supposed to. We have witnessed this behavior throughout history, more recently in WWII.

    Most Americans are very USA-centric and beLIEve the main stream media relative to the state of the globe. I used to buy into what I was told to think and feel. Until I didn’t.

    Please explore the following link on who owns the media. Six corporations own every bit of media. Does anyone else see this as a mass brainwashing to control the populace?

    http://theeconomiccollapseblog.com/archives/who-owns-the-media-the-6-monolithic-corporations-that-control-almost-everything-we-watch-hear-and-read

  • Lcpenneygal

    We are not a Democracy, but a Republic. One Nation, under God, with Liberty and justice for all. I’m sure you remember that Josh. Heaven forbid it ever be a Democracy… Things would be much worse if it were. Your 3 goals are as stated, 1. to remove all money from Politics…. Can you be more specific on this? Are you talking about monies strictly from corporations? Or are we talking all monies? Both individual, Small and Corp?
    2. End Corporate personhood? What does this mean? Get rid of CEO’s?
    and 3. Support OWS. Does this mean through funding of the so far 1600.00 in donations that you have recieved? if not where will this money be used? and should it be taxed? Your goals are so vague. Can you please be more specific. My question to you all is out of how many of you that come out on a regular basis, How many of you believe in God? I would really like an answer to that question. Because if you all succeed in making this a God less country, we are in worse shape then anything we could ever have, financially. Thank you for your time and I hope that you will answer my questions.

    • tvwav

      “Ain’t it like most people? I’m no different
      We love to talk on things we don’t know about”
      I don’t usually attempt to respond to persons who question the legitimacy of the occupy movement, as their minds are already made up and the entire purpose is to bait some one into an argument that can not be won. I don’t mean to question your sincerity, but technically speaking, a Republic IS a form of democracy- EG a subset of several “forms” of democratic government, and i might also point out that the rest of your supporting argument rests on recitation of the “pledge of allegiance” that did not exist until proposed by a Christian Socialist, (ain’t that a hoot), in 1892 – 116 years after the Declaration and more technically 104 years after we became one nation with the ratification of the constitution. (Of coarse the argument can be made that that question was not really settled until 1865, or even that it has still not been settled!) This pledge has been amended several times after coming into widespread use through a commercial for profit Columbus Day scheme to sell magazines to students- very American, don’t you think?- with the words “under god” not being added until 1954. All this by way of saying that the pledge makes a poor argument for or against the constitutionality of anything, nor could one say conclusively “Heaven forbid it ever be a Democracy… Things would be much worse if it were.” without further defining what you might mean by the term “democracy”, as there are localities in our country who practice more pure forms of democracy without seeming harm. Perhaps you are actually thinking of what is sometimes termed “mobocracy”,( or more appropriately ochlocracy before those who despise such rule sought to give it an uglier name), a state which will always occur at times in any form of democracy. As to your questions concerning the goals of the occupy movement, i could not speak for them specifically, though i am certain that if you wished to go and see for yourself how they operate and ask what they hope to achieve, you would be more well informed, and more well confused, for i have noted that those involved seem to encompass a very broad range of ideologies, ists, and isms; therefore if there are any of those that you hate, or love, you will surely find them. I think what they share in common is the sense that their government has been sold to the highest bidder, a situation that is neither new nor unfounded. Had Tennessee’s government not been bought by cotton wealth, we would have not been the last state to secede from the Union in June of 1861; just by way of pointing out how serious the ramifications of the situation may become, as this state bore the brunt of the war on the western front to satisfy the goals of the wealthy few over the welfare of the many. This is why East Tennessee has been staunchly Republican ever since; though this “reason” has long faded and the Republican party of today bears little if any resemblance to the party of Lincoln. Politics is a lot like religion- it is handed down through the generations, dogma intact, unless another “force”, IE Martin Luther, causes a change in belief systems- such as what happened in the Confederate South when the anti-Republican Democrats suddenly turned on them and sided with the Blacks, the Atheists, and the Homosexuals… but i digress.
      Corporate Person-hood does not refer to any specific “person”, but rather a litany of court decisions that have resulted in the treatment of a non-human entity: the corporation; as if it were a human being – culminating recently with the Citizens United case, where the purchasing of government can now be exercised more blatantly than ever. I believe many of the occupy supporters feel as i do, that our state houses, executive offices, and courts should have large “real estate” signs posted on them stating “Property for Sale… At Absolute Auction to the Highest Bidder”.
      As to fund raising, it is necessary for all organizations to have resources because, as the detractors so love to point out, “ain’t nothing free” not even freedom. As to taxation, well i suppose that is a matter for the IRS to determine. I have not yet heard anyone argue against rendering to Caesar what is Caesar’s… As to vagueness; how more vague could our Revolution have been? It took years just to figure out a constitution and we are still trying 235 years later to figure out what we/they meant. I believe that will go on as long as we exist- meaning both the US and OWS.
      As to your question of faith, i have observed protesters in prayer, and i think there are those there out of deep religious conviction. I know, nor have i ever known of any such an entity as a “godless nation”. I have never been sure as to what was meant by that phrase, as all peoples seem to practice some form of belief whether persecuted or not, state sanctioned or not. Perhaps you refer to things you have been told about other countries concerning intolerance of other points of view, suppression of ideas and other Torquemada like inquisitions where the a group of individuals, believing as Torquemada did, that they were the soul possessors of “Truth” and therefore compelled to force others to see that same truth. That is known as a Theocracy and those who founded our nation were very much opposed to that idea- much more so than today- as our forefathers refused to even so much as declare a generic national day of prayer; a practice we do routinely today. Whether or not our economic future depends on acceptance of a deity i can not say; except believing in a force that “will provide” seems to be at the heart of all religion: so perhaps in some wise you are correct. I can only caution you that if we are not careful; we will become the mobocracy we hate, the intolerance we despise, the evil we deplore and everything from our own worst nightmares will become our reality. That is the nature of “the human condition”.

      I know that reason fails in this age of twits and blurbs and few will read what has no ad hominem of violence or straw man of absurdity BUT

      …As for me- give me liberty or give me death
      http://www.law.ou.edu/ushistory/henry.shtml

  • Be aware

    Republic vs. Democracy, for those that are interested.

    I think an argument can be made that we are a corporatocracy…

    “The chief characteristic and distinguishing feature of a Democracy is: Rule by Omnipotent Majority. In a Democracy, The Individual, and any group of Individuals composing any Minority, have no protection against the unlimited power of The Majority. It is a case of Majority-over-Man.”

    “A Republic, on the other hand, has a very different purpose and an entirely different form, or system, of government. Its purpose is to control The Majority strictly, as well as all others among the people, primarily to protect The Individual’s God-given, unalienable rights and therefore for the protection of the rights of The Minority, of all minorities, and the liberties of people in general. The definition of a Republic is: a constitutionally limited government of the representative type, created by a written Constitution–adopted by the people and changeable (from its original meaning) by them only by its amendment–with its powers divided between three separate Branches: Executive, Legislative and Judicial. Here the term “the people” means, of course, the electorate.”

    “A corporatocracy, is that corporations, to a significant extent, have massive power over governments, including those governments nominally elected by the people. They exercise their power via corporate monopolies and mergers, and through their subsequent capacity to leverage broad economic interests, which allows them the luxury of being declared “too big to fail”; this is accomplished by legal mechanisms (i.e., lobbyists, campaign contributions to office holders and candidates, threats to leave the state or country for another with less oversight and/or more personally beneficial subsidies, etc.), which renders them immune to vague accusations and prosecution. It may also refer to an unrealized form of government or theoretical corporate governance in national or international affairs.”

    http://lexrex.com/enlightened/AmericanIdeal/aspects/demrep.html

  • Tools93Red

    Wonder who is paying for the sanitation support and the electricity they group is using?

  • Tools93Red

    One way to stop the lifetime politician is to have term limits for each level of government. Two terms and your out! This would eliminate the politician becoming a permanent fixture and stop all the campaigning contributions or should I call them what they are, bribes.

    • Has a clue

      and eliminate lobbying. So many problems, so little time to fix them.

      An excellent book by Strauss & Howe, The Fourth Turning, is an excellent read. We are approaching a fourth turning.

      “The Fourth Turning is a Crisis —a decisive era of secular upheaval, when the values regime propels the replacement of the old civic order with a new one. Old Artists disappear, Prophets enter elderhood, Nomads enter midlife, Heroes enter young adulthood—and a new generation of child Artists is born.”

      http://www.fourthturning.com/html/history___turnings.html

  • RON PAUL SUPPORTER

    Very good letter. All i have to say is VOTE RON PAUL 2012

  • Johanne

    Although I take issue with some of the statements posted here, I do think that “what are your intentions regarding local legislation?” is a good question, as is “why aren’t you presenting your petition for redress yet”. This is a personal reply, based on what I observed for myself, and not on behalf of the group. It is long, but I hope it helps illuminate the point.

    Occupy Nashville has been at the plaza for about 4 weeks now. In the first two weeks, the group agreed a code of conduct, defined their management plan for the protest space, narrowed the goals to the three you find on the website, and began organizing outreach to ensure wider participation before defining a more detailed petition for redress.

    in the third week, much energy was diverted to managing human relationships on the plaza. The occupiers claim that normal levels of local policing were absent. If police stopped responding to incidents on Broadway, we’d probably see complaints about that too. They are different police authorities (State vs Metro), so my example is not fully accurate, but I think you get my drift. Towards the middle of the third week, representatives of ON met with the Department of Safety but did not encounter a problem-solving mindset. Rather than find low-cost solutions together, new rules for the plaza were passed by fiat, and then the arrests began, at a cost which must be many multiples of the cost that could have been achieved with a more collaborative attitude. This destroyed week 3 as far as any work on actions to accomplish goals. In effect the occupiers were completely diverted from their core grievances to a defence of the First Amendment and also the Fourth, since there was no probable cause for their arrests.

    The fourth week has been consumed with re-establishing and better organizing the protest site, continuing outreach, and work on a number of direct actions. Today there will be educational outreach at the plaza about the influence of banks.

    My personal view is that we might well approach the city or state legislature for discussion, for example about corporate personhood. I do not think we want to speak via the filter of the media. We might look for a local resolution, supported by a ballot, as has been recently done in Boulder. We are not there yet, for some of the reasons I mentioned.

    You might reasonably argue that we would be further along if the energy spent on managing the protest space had instead been applied to developing actions for a resolution. That might be true, but likely it would be a well-written action conceived by only a few people. Instead, I hope that we will have an even better action plan, that has benefited from more people with more ideas, even if it took longer to get it.

    I think the comments about “you should be in Washington” or “you should be protesting Obama” are missing the point. The wealth inequality that many of us feel is the result of undue corporate influence has developed over 30 years, 5 presidents, 8 terms. It’s more fundamental than Obama. At some point we may have things that we want to say in Washington. Right now, we have a need to assemble together at home, in Tennessee.

    However, as far as WE THE ATTORNEYS, that’s a nice soundbite, but the people I saw forcibly removed from the plaza were not attorneys. They were PEOPLE, and attorneys only got involved afterwards.

    Throughout this activity, and all the ad hominem attacks and remarks about handouts, I have not yet met one person who has said to me “You are wrong, corporate influence in government is healthy and in fact we should have MORE of it”. I realize it can be hard to discover that you have common complaints with people that you don’t like. However I think the path to profound change almost always starts with a focus by a dedicated small group, openness to alliances across party lines, and finally sustained complaint by a large group of citizens. I see the first two elements at Occupy Nashville, and the third remains to be created.

  • Trailhiker

    Nice letter, but they will still shoot you in the head with tear gas canisters if they can get away with it – thats how our Government works. A lot of skulls got smashed-in back in the 60′s – it’s coming.

  • MerryinMemphis

    That’s a great letter, very well written. Lotsa words saying…..what? Thank you police for not injuring any of us while we were being arrested? We’ve got potty breaks handled now? This is a lovely clean area for our camping party? “We are here on Legislative Plaza because we are deeply concerned by undue corporate influence in government.” Is that statement supposed to shed light on the REASON people are sitting in tents, chanting and holding hand drawn signs? I’m not against protesting or protesters, I’m happy you all are having a great time. I would just like for one person to please give me a solid reason for occupying the plaza. Exactly who or what are you hoping to influence or change? I guess I just don’t understand this particular protest and am looking for answers. Especially since no one in the entire country has heard a peep about the ‘occupy nashville’ group since the arrests have stopped.

  • Anonymous

    As one who was damaged in the dot com fraud perpetrated by business and Wall Street firms and stock analysts, I learned about Wall Street the hard way. Then they did it again by inflating the housing fraud, collecting fees for loans and bogus financial instruments, it is an outrage. The occupy movements send a clear signal and give legislators a feel for the growing public resentment. This will result in regulations to better prevent this fraud in the future. This is what they are accomplishing. It is a healthy sign that democracy works.

  • Anonymous

    What does protesting Rumsfield have anything to do with your three stated goals? Absolutely NOTHING!!!!!! Just a bunch of spoiled brats whining that is all and throwing a fit. hahahahahahahahahahaha!!!!!!!


Occupy NATO 2012   |   Needs of the occupiers   |   FAQ   Number of Occupy protesters arrested counter